Tag Archives: Praying

What did Stephen Chow mean about Praying Mantis?

In “Shao-lin soccer,” Stephen Chow mocks a skinny kid who shows him a praying mantis form and says “you’re giving kung fu a bad name.” In an earlier movie I read that he killed a master of a “lost” praying mantis style with a can of bug spray.
Is Praying Mantis considered less effective for combat by other kung fu practitioners?
I’m not sure what he meant, Northern or Southern. I looked into the Wiki and other places for evidence of what he meant, and couldn’t find anything, just that there’s several types usually classed as northern and southern. Is there something wrong with one of them?

Is there a Kung Fu place in Vancouver, WA-Portland, OR area where I can learn She-Quan?

Is there even a place where you can just learn She-Quan or is it a sub-catagory along with Praying Mantis and others?

How can you possibly say all arts are equal?

How can you say that all arts, Tai Chi, Praying Mantis Kung Fu, Aikido, MMA, Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, etc, are all equally effective systems?

To be effective, a method must have experimentation and observation, just like any science.

Full contact provides that experimentation. Video provides ample chance for observation.

Speaking of which, MMA contests like the UFC have proven time and time again which techniques and which strategies work.

And before you launch into a speech about the differences between the UFC and a “real fight” (which often exists in some weird fantasy world) let me say right now that I have been a police officer and am currently a martial arts instructor for the military. I KNOW what a real fight looks like. It looks a lot more like the UFC than it does any “traditional” martial arts class I’ve seen.

I just don’t understand the mentality involved in the “all arts are equal” philosophy.

I’d love it if I got answers from both the “all arts are equal” folks and the “90% of traditional arts are bullshit” camp.

Let me have it. Ten points to the best argument, no matter if I agree with you or not.

Which kung fu style should I learn?

I’ve been looking around after deciding to take up a martial art. After some consideration, I settled on the Chinese Shaolin kung fu. However, there are a few other specializations. Tiger, White Crane, Dragon, and Praying Mantis are the styles I’ve been considering. I mainly want to learn for self-defense and self-enlightenment reasons, as well as spiritual–I’m persuing Buddhism and the Tao as well. I’m fifteen years old, living in a small mountain town in Pennsylvania, north America, so there aren’t really any places to learn around me. I’m not too sure about White Crane because it doesn’t seem to be in practice much anymore. I like Dragon, because it mixes strength with evasion. Also, it has chi-building associated with it, which I’m very interested in; the main reason I didn’t like the Tiger style is because apparently it focuses on brute strength rather than some strength added with chi. Praying Mantis seems well-suited for me; a mix of power and evasion, as well as chi. I can’t decide on a Northern or Southern style, though. The fact of the matter is that I can’t really find that much information on any of the styles, what they’re mainly suited for, and what they look like. I want to be sure of it, because choosing a style is a commitment and it’ll take me years to learn. If someone could help me pick a style that’s fitted to me, I’d be grateful. Also, if anyone knows of any schools in NEPA it would be helpful. Here’s what I’m looking for in a style.
I want a good mix of strength and evasion, definitely with chi as well (i.e. the style focuses on building chi and incorporating it into the fighting style). I’m a fifteen year old male. I’m relatively tall, but I’m a bit on the skinny side; not much muscle. I’d like something acrobatic as well, but that’s not necessary. If someone could help me pick a style as listed above, or provide more info, a source I could look at, other styles, etc. that would help me make a decision myself, I’d be grateful. Wikipedia definitely isn’t doing the trick. Up until now I’ve been using shaolin.com, but that’s not too great either. Thanks very much.

Which kung fu style should I learn?

I’ve been looking around after deciding to take up a martial art. After some consideration, I settled on the Chinese Shaolin kung fu. However, there are a few other specializations. Tiger, White Crane, Dragon, and Praying Mantis are the styles I’ve been considering. I mainly want to learn for self-defense and self-enlightenment reasons, as well as spiritual–I’m persuing Buddhism and the Tao as well. I’m fifteen years old, living in a small mountain town in Pennsylvania, north America, so there aren’t really any places to learn around me. I’m not too sure about White Crane because it doesn’t seem to be in practice much anymore. I like Dragon, because it mixes strength with evasion. Also, it has chi-building associated with it, which I’m very interested in; the main reason I didn’t like the Tiger style is because apparently it focuses on brute strength rather than some strength added with chi. Praying Mantis seems well-suited for me; a mix of power and evasion, as well as chi. I can’t decide on a Northern or Southern style, though. The fact of the matter is that I can’t really find that much information on any of the styles, what they’re mainly suited for, and what they look like. I want to be sure of it, because choosing a style is a commitment and it’ll take me years to learn. If someone could help me pick a style that’s fitted to me, I’d be grateful. Also, if anyone knows of any schools in NEPA it would be helpful. Here’s what I’m looking for in a style.
I want a good mix of strength and evasion, definitely with chi as well (i.e. the style focuses on building chi and incorporating it into the fighting style). I’m a fifteen year old male. I’m relatively tall, but I’m a bit on the skinny side; not much muscle. I’d like something acrobatic as well, but that’s not necessary. If someone could help me pick a style as listed above, or provide more info, a source I could look at, other styles, etc. that would help me make a decision myself, I’d be grateful. Wikipedia definitely isn’t doing the trick. Up until now I’ve been using shaolin.com, but that’s not too great either. Thanks very much.